Which AI do you think is currently the best when it comes to images? ChatGPT or Gemini’s Nano Banana? I decided to put both to the test, using the same prompts to see which one can truly deliver when it comes to image generation and editing.
But first, I want to let you know that this isn’t about declaring a “winner” in the traditional sense. This is all about personal taste, aesthetics, and what resonates with you as a viewer. So less of an AI award and more of a curiosity since there have been many AI images sprouting lately.
Though I want to tell you right now. The results amazed me (really)… Let’s see how both performed.
Disclaimer: While these are general suggestions, it’s important to conduct thorough research and due diligence when selecting AI tools. We do not endorse or promote any specific AI tools mentioned here. This article is for educational and informational purposes only. It is not intended to provide legal, financial, or clinical advice. Always comply with HIPAA and institutional policies. For any decisions that impact patient care or finances, consult a qualified professional.
Image Generation: Creating a Realistic Moment in the Mountains
First up, I asked both AIs to create a simple yet challenging scene:
“Create a realistic image of a man drinking coffee in the mountains.”
Here’s ChatGPT’s result:
ChatGPT’s attempt was… not quite there. While the overall concept was okay (portrait and all), the skin texture didn’t look natural, the eyes had that weird lifeless quality that tends to give away that an image is AI-generated. I don’t even understand where it’s looking at.
The creases on his jacket look cool, though!
But other little details, like how the trees look too soft, the little botched finger, they just didn’t feel right.
Now here’s the output from Gemini’s Nano Banana:
Gemini’s Nano Banana, on the other hand, nailed it. The textures were spot-on. The shadows, realistic smile, and even the lighting felt natural. And look at those ice caps in the mountains and the smoke from the mug!
The only strange thing I found was his fingers (would have been perfect), but overall, the image felt much more lifelike.
No competition here, Gemini takes the lead.
Image Editing: Making a Couple on Swings Look Real
Next, I uploaded an image and told both AIs:
“Edit this image. I want to see a cute couple on the swings. Make it as realistic as possible.”
This is the original image (clumsily shot on an iPhone):
Here’s ChatGPT’s result:
ChatGPT’s output left much to be desired. The couple didn’t quite fit in the scene, and the hands and feet looked off, almost like they were added in as an afterthought. The guy even seemed to be floating in mid-air, rather than sitting in the swing! It was clear this was an AI attempt, and not a very convincing one.
But points to adding a reflection in the puddle, though (see man on the right).
Now here’s the output from Gemini’s Nano Banana:
When I gave the same task to Gemini’s Nano Banana, the result was surprising.
The couple blended seamlessly into the background, and the details, from the plants to their facial expressions, looked completely natural. Has AI gotten this good? You could’ve easily mistaken it for a real photograph. The smiles on their faces were genuine, and the composition was perfect. This was AI working at its best.
The Verdict: Nano Banana Wins—But It’s Not That Simple
So, in this quick experiment, Gemini’s Nano Banana took the crown in both image generation and editing.
But here’s the thing, this doesn’t mean ChatGPT or any other AI is out of the game. It’s a matter of evolution. Maybe the prompts I used weren’t the best fit, or maybe ChatGPT just needs a little more time to catch up. AI is always improving, and who knows, next time, ChatGPT could be the one surprising us all.
You might find ChatGPT’s images to be better; it’s also a matter of preference.
That said, Nano Banana really stands out right now. Its ability to produce highly detailed, realistic images is impressive. From the textures to the lighting, it feels like you’re looking at a photograph rather than an AI-generated image. But, as always, we’re just scratching the surface of what AI is capable of.
Unlock the Full Power of ChatGPT With This Copy-and-Paste Prompt Formula!
Download the Complete ChatGPT Cheat Sheet! Your go-to guide to writing better, faster prompts in seconds. Whether you’re crafting emails, social posts, or presentations, just follow the formula to get results instantly.
Save time. Get clarity. Create smarter.
Final Thoughts
AI in image generation and editing is exciting. Whether you’re creating, designing content, or just having fun with these tools, the potential is huge.
For now, Gemini’s Nano Banana holds the crown, but we’re just getting started. The evolution of AI is rapid, and who knows what’ll come next?
I also want to let you know that there are potential dangers in these things. So always do your due diligence and only share what you’re comfortable with.
What about you? Have you played around with these tools yet? What do you think AI’s role will be in creative projects moving forward? I’d love to hear your thoughts. After all, AI is here to stay, and it’s only getting better. Let us know in the comments!
If you want to learn more about AI and other cool AI tools, make sure to subscribe to our newsletter! We also have a free AI resource page where we share the latest tips, tricks, and news to help you make the most of technology.
To go deeper, check out PIMDCON 2025 — The Physician Real Estate & Entrepreneurship Conference. You’ll gain real-world strategies from doctors who are successfully integrating AI and business for massive results.
See you again next time! As always, make it happen.
Disclaimer: The information provided here is based on available public data and may not be entirely accurate or up-to-date. It’s recommended to contact the respective companies/individuals for detailed information on features, pricing, and availability. This article is for educational and informational purposes only. It is not intended to provide legal, financial, or clinical advice. Always comply with HIPAA and institutional policies. For any decisions that impact patient care or finances, consult a qualified professional.
IF YOU WANT MORE CONTENT LIKE THIS, MAKE SURE YOU SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER TO GET UPDATES ON THE LATEST TRENDS FOR AI, TECH, AND SO MUCH MORE.
Peter Kim, MD is the founder of Passive Income MD, the creator of Passive Real Estate Academy, and offers weekly education through his Monday podcast, the Passive Income MD Podcast. Join our community at the Passive Income Doc Facebook Group.
Further Reading